That's been my viewpoint for quite a while. Both have wrecked decent situations they walked into. Replacing the popular Fridge in favor of Edsall should get that AD fired.
P simply is indefensible at this point. Just a lot of instances of really bad judgement. You don't expect from 62 year old with tons of head coaching experience.
Of the two, I think Edsall has a better chance of improving next year. Cthe question is, if he "improves " to 7 wins by year three, what then? You forced out a guy that won nine games for guy to "break through" and win 7 in year three? That sort of math doesn't add up for a fan base, and unlike at UConn, he won't have a whole throng of supporters saying "this is his program and he will be here as long as he wants"