"Not a BCS level offense" -- C'MON MAN!!!!! After Dan O left there's no question the passing game has not been of high BCS quality. But the running game most certainly had been until GDL arrived on the scene.
And the notion that UConn's 'boring' offense had anything to do with being left out in CR is beyond laughable. The crazy Oregon & Oklahoma State style offenses is a relatively new phenomenon. Until very recently Big 10 football wasn't exactly known for its run & fun & gun offenses. Losing and the unserious hire of P had much more to do with losing out to Louisville. If the Michigan game had been at the Rent in 201o or 2011 with that crowd and that TV rating, we would be in much better shape in that regard. As it is, UConn did itself a lot of CR good last Saturday.
I'm not saying anything re CR because we've beat that to death and none of us have any actual facts (other than we got left out).
And yes - we did have a BCS level running game prior to 2011. But that was because we had NFL caliber backs. Yes, the line was better and the blocking schemes were better, but McCombs isn't in the same class.
But this is telling:
2008____62/13/109 (the last year of DB - and if your running game is top 15 you don't need a passing game to win)
2009____57/39/61 (Todman - who was very good BUT not as good as DB or the combo of DB and Dixon prior - we were also helped a lot by the emergence of Easley)
2010____96/35/110 (Todman again - with NO passing game because nobody could catch (and maybe because of the Nick Williams conspiracy))
2011____108/97/84 (McCombs era begins. He isn't as good as Todman or DB or Dixon or Cauley (and you wouldn't trade any of the above for McCombs)
Bottom line - we don't have 1 back on the roster that is anywhere near as good as Todman. And with McCombs rushing for over 1000 yards as a freshman we still had the 97th ranked run game in 2011.
If Todman hadn't left early, he probably runs for 1400 yards easy and we end up 7-5 at least - even with P coaching and the GDL blocking scheme.
2012 and 2013 would be the same - and P should still be canned. But I just don't buy the narrative that he ruined something great. Because the 2 thing that was most instrumental in making it great was gone when he walked in the door. A gritty QB who knew how to survive and an NFL caliber running back. If Whitmer/McCombs were running the 2010 squad we don't go to the Fiesta Bowl. And if we do, its because of Whitmer, not McCombs.