Huh? Your argument is naïve at best, non-sensical at worst. Have you ever played on an organized sports team?
The captain of a team is not the best player on the team (although it does often work out that way). Point production is irrelevant. It is about who is taking the lead of the guys in the locker room, on the ice, and away from the rink. The captain is supposed to be one of the leaders and a guy who has the respect of his team--it should have nothing to do with skill level or production.
No offense, but this is just an asinine argument to make. To question the captaincy because of his point production?!