- Joined
- Aug 24, 2011
- Messages
- 22,660
- Reaction Score
- 8,651
I remember being in the Rent in (from memory) ‘03 when we fell behind Western Michigan 17-0, and were backed up inside our own 5. I remember a friend asking me and my son why we weren’t concerned. We both thought our team with Orlovsky was better than them and had more than enough time to make it right, and they did. I remember in ‘13 when, at 0-9, we fell behind Temple 21-0 on the road, and had every reason to just give up on the game and the season. And then we won 28-21, and won out the season from there. And, for the rest of my time, I’ll remember going downstairs at halftime today, down 20-3 and having been totally outplayed, and anger eating. I knew the game wasn’t over, but I didn’t give us much of a chance either. And then we snuck closer, and then out of nowhere (because they remained as iffy in the first half as they were last week) the defense came back big time. And then the forced QB change and about 9 minutes of perfect football, marred only by the missed FG that, instead of icing the game, left the outcome in some doubt until the last 30 seconds. We’ll get into all of this in more depth in a minute, but no one should lose the fact that we played perfect defensively in the 4th Q, without which what happened on offense wouldn’t even have mattered.
O.K., so let’s start with offense. We had really good drives to start each half, but otherwise, until the QB change, struggled mightily. This is what I’ll say — I thought Evers the last two games played better, and was completing a higher percentage of passes and making some intelligent runs. But — well, two buts actually, and neither could be ignored. The first is that he simply doesn’t look at secondary receivers. He doesn’t. If the play works he can get it to the guy he has in mind before the snap, but that won’t always be where the highest percentage or yardage is. And the second, not unrelated, is that even when he is completing an acceptable percentage of passes, the yardage per throw and yardage per reception is so damn low that you can’t run an effective offense with it. It’s one thing when a QB has a bad game — like against Rice — but our problem is that even when he has a good game throwing the ball, it isn’t enough. And unless we can simply overpower an opponent and run it down their throats — difficult to do down two starting OL and when the defense isn’t worried about passing because even if the QB hits the receiver we’re not gaining enough yards to hurt them — we are stuck struggling on offense. And then, with the QB change, everything changed. Not that JF was perfect either. Far from it. But even being far from perfect, him being in lets WRs make plays (and Bell, despite the drops, made maybe the biggest play of the game with the long reception on the left sideline), and opens up the running game more, and, if nothing else, seems to increase everyone elses’ confidence and competence. Yes, Mora sees them at practice every day, and Mora knows a trillion times what I know about football, but I’m not an idiot either and we really need to stop having this debate and let Fagnano finish the season out. There’s every chance that isn’t an issue depending on Evers’ injury anyway. And, while it won’t be what we’re talking about, kudos for Edwards and the OL for the last run.
Not a good enough day for special teams. We didn’t punt a lot, but Freeman obviously missed a crucial kick (not beating on the kid — he hadn’t missed from under 50 in like two months but it is what it is) and, again, we’re giving up far more return yards than we’re getting (this week on punts). But the game wasn’t won, lost, or even heavily influenced by special teams this week.
So the defense was simply handled by UAB for the first half, largely the way Georgia State handled it. We mostly contain huge plays, but running against us is way too easy and when you combine that with the ability to complete short passes — well, you go from owning defensive third downs, as we did for most of the season, to suddenly allowing teams to convert half of their third downs. And then the second half occurred. And we contained the run, pressured and sacked the QB, generated takeaways and made plays. Two entirely different halves defensively, but the second half was great and without it we wouldn’t be talking about QB play because nothing JF did would have mattered. Credit where it is due. It’s a shame we’re losing as many D starters as we are, because this unit is good. Also, don’t know what happened to Jordan Wright, but at some point Malcolm Bell took over (and, as when he took over for Chadwick, did well).
So that’s it. Unlike our first six wins this year, this one was on the road and this one required a once a decade type comeback. Both great to watch and more of an accomplishment than some of the others. I’m sorry that, on another thread, some people think I’m being harsh when I point out that none of the 7 teams we’ve beaten our good. I don’t know why. I’m not doubting that this team is obviously better than what we’ve been putting up with since 2010, I’m not doubting how much fun the six game homestand was and I’m not minimizing how exciting the second half was today. But facts are still facts. Look at the ratings of who we have beaten — it is what it is. I‘m not one to bury my head in the sand and pretend that this is the same as being 7-3 would have been when we were in the Big East, or even the American. But it also doesn’t mean that we’re not 7-3 — we are and I’m happy for the accomplishment and the winning football I’ve watched. A week off to recover, and then off to the Dome. That will be a tough game — Syracuse is much better than anyone we’ve beaten yet, and probably significantly better than anyone we’ve played. It will be interesting to see who is taking snaps. But then, assuming no screw up against UMass, the bowl game, even against a 6-6 G-5 team, will give us a chance to measure ourselves and try to get a win against someone better than anyone we’ve beaten so far. But no looking ahead. Let’s use the off week and get ready for 60 minutes of our best football of the year up in Southern Ontario. And let’s spend a few days enjoying the afterglow of this great comeback.
O.K., so let’s start with offense. We had really good drives to start each half, but otherwise, until the QB change, struggled mightily. This is what I’ll say — I thought Evers the last two games played better, and was completing a higher percentage of passes and making some intelligent runs. But — well, two buts actually, and neither could be ignored. The first is that he simply doesn’t look at secondary receivers. He doesn’t. If the play works he can get it to the guy he has in mind before the snap, but that won’t always be where the highest percentage or yardage is. And the second, not unrelated, is that even when he is completing an acceptable percentage of passes, the yardage per throw and yardage per reception is so damn low that you can’t run an effective offense with it. It’s one thing when a QB has a bad game — like against Rice — but our problem is that even when he has a good game throwing the ball, it isn’t enough. And unless we can simply overpower an opponent and run it down their throats — difficult to do down two starting OL and when the defense isn’t worried about passing because even if the QB hits the receiver we’re not gaining enough yards to hurt them — we are stuck struggling on offense. And then, with the QB change, everything changed. Not that JF was perfect either. Far from it. But even being far from perfect, him being in lets WRs make plays (and Bell, despite the drops, made maybe the biggest play of the game with the long reception on the left sideline), and opens up the running game more, and, if nothing else, seems to increase everyone elses’ confidence and competence. Yes, Mora sees them at practice every day, and Mora knows a trillion times what I know about football, but I’m not an idiot either and we really need to stop having this debate and let Fagnano finish the season out. There’s every chance that isn’t an issue depending on Evers’ injury anyway. And, while it won’t be what we’re talking about, kudos for Edwards and the OL for the last run.
Not a good enough day for special teams. We didn’t punt a lot, but Freeman obviously missed a crucial kick (not beating on the kid — he hadn’t missed from under 50 in like two months but it is what it is) and, again, we’re giving up far more return yards than we’re getting (this week on punts). But the game wasn’t won, lost, or even heavily influenced by special teams this week.
So the defense was simply handled by UAB for the first half, largely the way Georgia State handled it. We mostly contain huge plays, but running against us is way too easy and when you combine that with the ability to complete short passes — well, you go from owning defensive third downs, as we did for most of the season, to suddenly allowing teams to convert half of their third downs. And then the second half occurred. And we contained the run, pressured and sacked the QB, generated takeaways and made plays. Two entirely different halves defensively, but the second half was great and without it we wouldn’t be talking about QB play because nothing JF did would have mattered. Credit where it is due. It’s a shame we’re losing as many D starters as we are, because this unit is good. Also, don’t know what happened to Jordan Wright, but at some point Malcolm Bell took over (and, as when he took over for Chadwick, did well).
So that’s it. Unlike our first six wins this year, this one was on the road and this one required a once a decade type comeback. Both great to watch and more of an accomplishment than some of the others. I’m sorry that, on another thread, some people think I’m being harsh when I point out that none of the 7 teams we’ve beaten our good. I don’t know why. I’m not doubting that this team is obviously better than what we’ve been putting up with since 2010, I’m not doubting how much fun the six game homestand was and I’m not minimizing how exciting the second half was today. But facts are still facts. Look at the ratings of who we have beaten — it is what it is. I‘m not one to bury my head in the sand and pretend that this is the same as being 7-3 would have been when we were in the Big East, or even the American. But it also doesn’t mean that we’re not 7-3 — we are and I’m happy for the accomplishment and the winning football I’ve watched. A week off to recover, and then off to the Dome. That will be a tough game — Syracuse is much better than anyone we’ve beaten yet, and probably significantly better than anyone we’ve played. It will be interesting to see who is taking snaps. But then, assuming no screw up against UMass, the bowl game, even against a 6-6 G-5 team, will give us a chance to measure ourselves and try to get a win against someone better than anyone we’ve beaten so far. But no looking ahead. Let’s use the off week and get ready for 60 minutes of our best football of the year up in Southern Ontario. And let’s spend a few days enjoying the afterglow of this great comeback.
Last edited: