Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="UcMiami, post: 3965882, member: 199"] Thanks - I finally followed the links and found the site and their mission and their rating system. Checked a sample movie - Psycho and found it scored 97 with most of the critics rating it 100 but a few mostly dating back to much earlier (1960) finding it too gross. So the perfect movies are in fact movies that all critics rate in the top range and has nothing to do with how they were made, or their casts, etc. But I find it interesting because a film like Casablanca had very mixed reviews when it was released so they didn't look too hard for the contemporary reviews for that film, but a film like Psycho they find enough contemporary reviews to down grade. Interesting note - Psycho and Notorious both have a bad review from the critics but they have more and more perfect reviews for the second. [/QUOTE]