Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="JonathanXIV, post: 3248430, member: 9217"] One (and there are more than a few) of the problems with your "analysis" of what team has more talent, is that it uses recruit rankings as if they are static. You presume that the ranking remains the same for all four years of a player's career. Even if the rankings are a valid means of measuring the talent of a player, it's certainly plausible that a #1 ranked player as a freshman doesn't perform as well as a lesser ranked player who is a senior. Was Collier the same player as a freshman than she was as a senior? Is anyone? [/QUOTE]