- Joined
- Sep 3, 2011
- Messages
- 4,731
- Reaction Score
- 18,267
There are some that use the KenPom argument, us being 1 in offense, but only 4 in defense. Yet they fail to recognize that the 4 in defense was in part due to our two best defenders either missing time or not being 100% for stretches. If anything we were just as good defensively as we were offensively in March. Had DC and SC been healthy all year, I'm honestly not sure we'd have lost more than the 1 game against Creighton where they caught fire with DC on the bench with two fouls. Between the talent level, the perfect roster construction and coaching, give me that Husky team every time. ESPN came out with an article ranking the best college basketball teams of the past 25 years after the 2023 NC, and our 1999 team was number one. As good and gritty as that 99 team was, I honestly think the 2024 team beats them 8 out of 10 if you look at talent and execution. Steph would have given Rip fits. 2024 was so much bigger and more skilled top to bottom. I honestly don't know how the 99 team would have scored with a small Khalid, Ricky, Free & Jake being relied on as scorers with Cling in the middle. I could easily see the 24 team pummeling 99 in a couple of those games, and 99 grinding out a couple of close wins. I'd like anyone that thinks otherwise to tell me exactly how the 99 team was beating 24 as they were very reliant on one dominant iso scorer we had an answer for. The era excuse only carries so much weight as overall talent, analytics and shooting have come so far since the 80s/90s.We did that to Illinois with maybe our C+ game. We shot terribly. Shot poorly against Purdue too - and beat the second best team in the nation by 15. And we probably would have been even better down the stretch had Castle not missed so much time and had his growth stunted. Clingan maybe a little bit too.
People point to the 2012 Anthony Davis Kentucky team as the most talented title team recently (although they lost the SEC title to Vandy). Davis was very raw offensively at that point (only had 3 or 4 games all year with 20 points) but certainly was a unicorn on defense and has proven to be an MVP level player at the next level. But looking at other weapons - Castle is already better than MKG ever was (Bradley Beal was right there to pair with Kemba, you Hornet idiots). Newton and Teague is no contest at point guard. Cam was a much more complete player than Doron Lamb. Cam was in some ways a unicorn on offense with his efficiency as both a shooter and playmaker at the two - you won’t find those numbers for very many other players. Karaban and Terrence Jones are maybe a wash.
I get the AD love might sway some people, but I take last years UConn team a million times out of a million.
2024 was a Picasso of a basketball team, and we're unlikely to see anything like it again for a long time. The doubters to 2024s dominance are relying more on prideful era takes than they are breaking it down player for player and recognizing the advancement of the game, and how well that Uconn team ran it. It was so good it felt like they were totally comfortable toying with you for a half, fully confident they could hit the gas after halftime. They were practically playing another sport altogether. Size-wise, they were constructed like an NBA team.
I've seen some of the Rupp lunies argue that their 1996 team was better, as they had the second highest margin of victory for a champion (by over 2 pts less than the 2024 Uconn team). That was a very good team and given lead by Pitino, may have posed stylistic challenges similar to StJ last year. If we locked them up in the halfcourt and executed the standard full shot clock offense to numb them into the coma like we did with most teams last year, I think we take best of 10 there. You just cannot underestimate what making a team defend for 30 seconds does to set tempo/pace. I've also heard all about the Nova teams, but we would have done exactly what we did to all three point shooting teams last year and left Cling back to protect the rim and let our large guards smother the three point line. They would have been forced to beat us with mid range jumpers. That 2024 team had an answer for everything defensively. The only kryponite it had was getting Cling in foul trouble, which Illinois tried. I'll hand it to Underwood as it was not a bad strategy and with the right refs, could have worked. It failed miserably that night.
Last edited: