ROY | The Boneyard

ROY

Not in any official capacity.

A panel of sportswriters votes on it. They each pick first through third place, with 5 pts going to each first place vote, 3 pts going to each second place vote, and one pt going to each third place vote. Add them all up, and the rookie with the most points wins ROY (ironically enough).
 
do any of them watch any full wnba games? or at minimum, give a bit of personal research? ... not to be cynical, but i daresay i could guess the answers

i hope the they choose the right people to listen to
 
PacoSwede said:
do any of them watch any full wnba games? or at minimum, give a bit of personal research? ... not to be cynical, but i daresay i could guess the answers

i hope the they choose the right people to listen to
Expand ...
What do you mean by personal research?
 
Well you really can't go wrong with either choice. Obviously I'd vote for Pheesa, but historically the scoring leader wins the award. Most of the voters likely have not watched every game and may not do detailed enough analysis to look at efficiency numbers, etc. If they only look at PPG, then yeah they will vote for Arike. If they look at everything, they should vote for Pheesa...

I'm glad at least one sportswriter (was it Voepel?) came out and said she'd vote for Pheesa and explained why. Maybe that will help educate others who have not paid as much attention...
 
Do we know when the awards are announced?
 
Partly how do you compare a guard versus a forward? Forwards are going to get more rebounds, as Pheesa did, guards are going to get more assists, as Arike did. Pheesa had more steals but Arike, playing aggressively, had far more free throws and three pointers. A ROY case for either is justified.
 
WNBA stats are wrong. I was comparing Arike and Pheesa when I noticed that EDD was listed as first in free throws made with 108 and Arike wasn’t in top five so I checked and discovered Arike with 135 free throws made, 27 more than the alleged leader. I think sometimes free throws are indicative of a player’s impact as it shows both her aggressiveness and how closely the opponent has to play her. Now in second place in scoring, she also could overtake Grinder with a strong performance and a subpar one by Grinder in final game. She’s making a strong argument for ROY. Right now she is the Dallas Wings. Where would they be with Cambage? Of course where would Lynx be with Maya?
 
The WNBA stats page is a bit funky. Every so often, they just drop a player out of a stat category. For several weeks McCowan was not listed in the rebounding, but was in scoring, etc.

Dokey said:
WNBA stats are wrong. I was comparing Arike and Pheesa when I noticed that EDD was listed as first in free throws made with 108 and Arike wasn’t in top five so I checked and discovered Arike with 135 free throws made, 27 more than the alleged leader. I think sometimes free throws are indicative of a player’s impact as it shows both her aggressiveness and how closely the opponent has to play her. Now in second place in scoring, she also could overtake Grinder with a strong performance and a subpar one by Grinder in final game. She’s making a strong argument for ROY. Right now she is the Dallas Wings. Where would they be with Cambage? Of course where would Lynx be with Maya?
Expand ...
 
Bigboote said:
The WNBA stats page is a bit funky. Every so often, they just drop a player out of a stat category. For several weeks McCowan was not listed in the rebounding, but was in scoring, etc.
Expand ...
Getting stats wrong does not reflect well on WNBA.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Online statistics

Members online
29
Guests online
1,462
Total visitors
1,491
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Share This Page

Forum statistics

Threads
163,987
Messages
4,377,753
Members
10,167
Latest member
CTFan142


.
..
Top Bottom