Rothstein: Social Media is responsible for players transferring | The Boneyard

Rothstein: Social Media is responsible for players transferring

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
13,761
Reaction Score
143,889
Not surprised Rothstein is the guy making this argument, but I would expect him to at least address some of the actual reasons players transfer, like playing time issues and coaching changes, instead of just blaming it on social media. Yeesh.

Observations: Cal can be even more complete, dynamic in 2016-17

The transfer epidemic is directly related to the rise of social media

One of the biggest issues in college basketball right now is the amount of kids that are leaving schools on an annual basis and that's directly related to the rise of Twitter over the last 5-7 years.

Like everyone in this world, college athletes have an ego and part of the reason why they're so prone to make a change in where they're playing college basketball is due to the enjoyment they receive when their name is constantly posted across a social media platform.

Fighting through adversity and building calluses through life experience is something that's a thing of the past and that's reiterated by the way players change programs at the grassroots level prior to ever stepping foot on a college campus.

But there's also no doubt that the attention that comes with being a transfer at the Division I level augments the desire of a kid to make a change -- especially if he's going to be immediately eligible for next season.

The rules don't make much sense, but they are what they are.

And the fact that programs can add players without them having to sit out because they're a college graduate makes the players who fit that criteria part of a special fraternity that is starting to feel like a watered down version of NBA free agency.

Assistant coaches from all over the country put lists together all season of guys who can potentially be eligible for the next year without sitting out and those players -- who normally boast marginal statistics -- become a viral name on social media for a month to six weeks before they make a decision.

Part of it is because they can help a team.

Part of it is because they're part of a select circle who can actually play immediately without sitting out.

But most of it is due to the fact that they enjoy the attention that comes with being re-recruited after spending the last few seasons as an ancillary piece to the puzzle at a program that might have been off-the-radar in terms of the national landscape.
 

4in16

uses the force
Joined
Oct 30, 2014
Messages
1,993
Reaction Score
4,716
Says the guy who practically lives on social media and his Twitter account.
 

Huskyforlife

Akokbouk
Joined
Feb 19, 2013
Messages
12,507
Reaction Score
51,515
Don't most kids claim they feel stressed during the recruiting process?
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2015
Messages
4,272
Reaction Score
35,409
My problem with this anti-transfer wave is that while it may be inconvenient for coaches who worked hard recruiting players, the right to transfer is absolutely a benefit to the student athletes. They can find the right system, move closer to home, or just change universities if they don't like theirs.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
9,379
Reaction Score
23,676
Fighting through adversity and building calluses through life experience is something that's a thing of the past and that's reiterated by the way players change programs at the grassroots level prior to ever stepping foot on a college campus.

Sizzling take here.
 

joober jones

Finally Non-Fat Guy
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
4,737
Reaction Score
9,654
Fighting through adversity and building calluses through life experience is something that's a thing of the past and that's reiterated by the way players change programs at the grassroots level prior to ever stepping foot on a college campus.

Sizzling take here.

Now I want the sizzling seafood platter at Som Siam. I think I'm going to go out and get it.
 

Rico444

In the mix for six
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
8,744
Reaction Score
30,824
And meanwhile, if a coach decides he wants to jump to the NBA or a bigger university, a kid that committed to that coach could be left hanging, without ever playing for the coach.

But social media, guys.
 
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
1,142
Reaction Score
2,896
What they should do is allow a student to transfer at any time, at will, for any reason, and be immediately eligible. Would suck for coaches and schools, but boy, would that ever be fun.
 
Joined
Aug 31, 2011
Messages
2,957
Reaction Score
5,401
Rothstein hates that kids are allowed to transfer and hates that kids are allowed to test the draft waters before making important decisions.

He's either a) a moron; or b) just sucking up to coaches.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2014
Messages
5,290
Reaction Score
19,770
His "correlation" is two stats that are trending upwards, and nothing further. That's about as lazy a job of researching as you can do

415113.image0.jpg
 

caw

Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
7,265
Reaction Score
13,588
Twitter/the Internet is probably partially to largely responsible. Kids and coaches know their options nowadays. In the past it was much harder to judge what other schools had openings, playing time, etc. not to mention rumors about coach firings, hirings, early entries, transfers, etc. Just like researching your first job, it's much easier these days to do with the Internet. Twitter just allows people to reach out to other programs with ease, because most coaches are now easy to contact. Again, it's like when you are job hunting and reach out on LinkedIn to someone at a potential company to judge the company atmosphere, pay, etc.

There are also coaches who use reporters and Twitter to help their recruiting. I think it was Pitino who said mid-season two years ago that he wanted to add one or two grad transfers for 15-16. It was quoted by reporters on Twitter and UL fans. I'm sure it got to grad transfers. He ended up with Lee and Lewis but that was at least one way he pushed the message to them.

Railing against transfers is idiotic. Why shouldn't a player be able to better their situation.

Edit: I do like how Cuse fans had been echoing Duke/K fans about the grad transfers (with Cuse fans esp ridiculing UConns use of it) and of course they are pretty happy to have just signed a grad transfer. Hypocrites.
 

BUHusky

The original. Accept no substitutes.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
1,455
Reaction Score
4,034
Death
Taxes
Rothstein's hot takes
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2015
Messages
4,272
Reaction Score
35,409
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
1,443
Reaction Score
3,785
Not surprised Rothstein is the guy making this argument, but I would expect him to at least address some of the actual reasons players transfer, like playing time issues and coaching changes, instead of just blaming it on social media. Yeesh.

Observations: Cal can be even more complete, dynamic in 2016-17

The transfer epidemic is directly related to the rise of social media

One of the biggest issues in college basketball right now is the amount of kids that are leaving schools on an annual basis and that's directly related to the rise of Twitter over the last 5-7 years.

Like everyone in this world, college athletes have an ego and part of the reason why they're so prone to make a change in where they're playing college basketball is due to the enjoyment they receive when their name is constantly posted across a social media platform.

Fighting through adversity and building calluses through life experience is something that's a thing of the past and that's reiterated by the way players change programs at the grassroots level prior to ever stepping foot on a college campus.

But there's also no doubt that the attention that comes with being a transfer at the Division I level augments the desire of a kid to make a change -- especially if he's going to be immediately eligible for next season.

The rules don't make much sense, but they are what they are.

And the fact that programs can add players without them having to sit out because they're a college graduate makes the players who fit that criteria part of a special fraternity that is starting to feel like a watered down version of NBA free agency.

Assistant coaches from all over the country put lists together all season of guys who can potentially be eligible for the next year without sitting out and those players -- who normally boast marginal statistics -- become a viral name on social media for a month to six weeks before they make a decision.

Part of it is because they can help a team.

Part of it is because they're part of a select circle who can actually play immediately without sitting out.

But most of it is due to the fact that they enjoy the attention that comes with being re-recruited after spending the last few seasons as an ancillary piece to the puzzle at a program that might have been off-the-radar in terms of the national landscape.
Mr. Rothstein is shot, the guy who repeats quotes daily, extremely odd.

Is never correct with his game predicitions, thinks everyone is brilliant and on the edge of being great.

And now he is blaming social media for transfers, get a clue Jon.

And please on another topic, pay the players, make it an open market.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
10,247
Reaction Score
33,127
Uh, they could have easily decided they're going to go forward with the process, does Rothstein really believe that the only path to the NBA or other avenues of professional basketball is the NBA combine?
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2014
Messages
5,290
Reaction Score
19,770
Rothstein is a terrible person, and kind of an idiot. He wrote a pretty tone-deaf piece on Brandon Austin that made him look like quite the rape apologist last year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
341
Guests online
2,050
Total visitors
2,391

Forum statistics

Threads
159,017
Messages
4,177,480
Members
10,049
Latest member
TNS


.
Top Bottom