OT: The Problem With Sports | The Boneyard

OT: The Problem With Sports

whaler11

Head Happy Hour Coach
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,374
Reaction Score
68,261
I'm bouncing between the NFL game and the MLB game.

You want to make money streaming games? Play them in less than 4 hours.

Every play in the NFL game was under review and the game took forever. This is with both teams never taking a chance and kicking every field goal available.

Somehow even after a million penalties in the football game - the MLB game is still in the 7th inning.

If it ends in 9 innings the baseball game is still going to come in at over 4 hours.

The 7th inning of the baseball game took an hour and six minutes.

Other than people like me who is going to watch neverending slogs?
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
87,430
Reaction Score
325,813
2ab0c931f2d276521914226fb5156505.jpg


But I hear ya...
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
20,536
Reaction Score
44,602
It's beyond a hassle. At current speeds it can't be done.
I'm a big streamer and its a pain in the . Its like the old days before remote controls. Find your programming and just watch it.
 

whaler11

Head Happy Hour Coach
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,374
Reaction Score
68,261
12:35 am for an east coast game that hasn't gone to extra innings yet.

This is why the EPL and USMNT grows. They get the games in at 2 hours.
 

whaler11

Head Happy Hour Coach
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,374
Reaction Score
68,261
4+ hours ending at almost 12:42 AM? Good luck with something besides the cable bundle.
 
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
3,941
Reaction Score
18,468
That game was ridiculous. 7 pitchers for one half inning? I'll take Overcoaching for $500 Alex.
 

pepband99

Resident TV nerd
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,715
Reaction Score
9,507
12:35 am for an east coast game that hasn't gone to extra innings yet.

This is why the EPL and USMNT grows. They get the games in at 2 hours.

...and they play at sane east coast times (or insane, in the case of some EPL morning games :) ). The NFL is seeking better ratings at better TV times, but the game length doesn't fit anymore. Baseball is even worse.
 
Joined
Feb 7, 2012
Messages
5,636
Reaction Score
24,828
A reach?

Streaming requires a level of attention I don't even have. Nevermind anyone younger than 35.
Streaming is great. It allows my wife to watch Grey's anatomy and how to get away with murder, I get to watch hunter Henry and cj Andersen for fantasy, and it counts as spending time together. The only thing not a win there was cj Anderson.
 

Alum86

Did they burn down the ROTC Hangar?
Joined
Oct 13, 2012
Messages
2,538
Reaction Score
2,955
I dropped rhe Sunday Ticket from DirecTV and stream out of market games on Kodi off the Amazon Fire Stick. Of course not as good as having the ticket, but money saved.
Changing between games is in minutes not instantaneous.
 

IMind

Wildly Inaccurate
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
1,868
Reaction Score
2,616
The only way I've found that flipping between games while streaming works is to have two devices going. Anything else just sucks beyond belief. Most interfaces are too cumbersome too... And god forbid you're not quite sure what you want to watch. The worst thing about the Roku is just trying to figure out what's on. The content is insane, but Roku has a ton of work to do on their interface. PlayStation Vue on the PlayStation 4 is pretty nice with the guide, etc. but using the controller as a remote annoys me... I have a remote that works on the PS4. I need to spend some time getting the buttons to work correctly. And if I want to watch anything outside of Vue... say Netflix... switching then becomes a pain.

As far as time goes, Hockey is pretty bad too... 20 minutes between periods? It's just an insane amount of time for absolutely nothing to happen. Baseball can be a pretty fast if theirs a pitching duel... but that's the only time. I thought at the beginning of the year they had managed to speed things up a bit... but that all seemed to go by the wayside. The one thing the NHL seems to have down though, is the review. They've already got the decision usually by the time a team decides to review. Baseball and football are intolerable because of reviews.
 

CTMike

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
11,415
Reaction Score
40,749
Baseball : 7 inning games, 120 game season, 1 pitching change per inning. Fixed!
 

The Funster

What?
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
2,949
Reaction Score
8,655
When I was a kid in the early 70s a ball game took about 2 hours. Relievers kill the game. They talk about time between pitches, blah, blah blah. Watch a game where both starters pitch 6 and I'll bet the time is pretty good. Once all the pitching changes start...it drags on and on. Starters are never going to nine innings anymore but they have to find a way to curtail pitching changes. Even allowing one per inning per team would help.
 

ConnHuskBask

Shut Em Down!
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
8,962
Reaction Score
32,833
It blows my mind they don't have multiple officials watching the games that make the final calls on reviews.

Coach challenges, umpires/refs off site get 1 minute to review the play and then call it in.

The NFL review times are particularly dreadful. Guess what if it takes 3 minutes and 100 different angles, it ain't conclusive!
 

MattMang23

Adding Nothing to the Conversation
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
5,150
Reaction Score
14,742
As far as time goes, Hockey is pretty bad too... 20 minutes between periods? It's just an insane amount of time for absolutely nothing to happen.

I'll defend hockey here. It's the fastest game on two feet but with a playing surface smaller than any game other than basketball, which means it is constant sprinting and direction-shifting. With lines on the ice for roughly thirty second intervals and teams running only three lines, you're in a constant sprint for thirty seconds, resting one minute, and repeating for twenty minutes, minus the play stoppages which are less time than breaks between downs in football (which, of course, happen constantly).

As brutally physical and draining as the game is, twenty minutes is completely necessary to recuperate so you're not putting an awful team on the ice in the third period. I could be persuaded that fifteen minutes is fine, but then you run into the issue of whether or not the ice surface can be cleaned efficiently in that time.
 

HuskyHawk

The triumphant return of the Blues Brothers.
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
31,984
Reaction Score
82,096
When I was a kid in the early 70s a ball game took about 2 hours. Relievers kill the game. They talk about time between pitches, blah, blah blah. Watch a game where both starters pitch 6 and I'll bet the time is pretty good. Once all the pitching changes start...it drags on and on. Starters are never going to nine innings anymore but they have to find a way to curtail pitching changes. Even allowing one per inning per team would help.

The worst are those lefty-righty situational changes. Bringing in a guy to get one out...then another change. Ugh. It's horrible. I barely watch baseball anymore.

I still love NFL games, but they are too long as well. College basketball is the best bet for me, bringing entertainment value in a roughly two hour time period. NBA games are too long and I don't enjoy the product. Soccer is good if it's a big, critical match like the World Cup or qualifying. Otherwise the fact that those guys pace themselves (unlike Hockey which has those long breaks) means they are barely trying for big parts of the match.
 

IMind

Wildly Inaccurate
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
1,868
Reaction Score
2,616
As brutally physical and draining as the game is, twenty minutes is completely necessary to recuperate so you're not putting an awful team on the ice in the third period. I could be persuaded that fifteen minutes is fine, but then you run into the issue of whether or not the ice surface can be cleaned efficiently in that time.

They usually have two Zamboni's going in the NHL so resurfacing isn't really an issue... and I give you that hockey is insanely physically... both my kids play . I spend about 20 hours a week in a rink. *laugh* USA Hockey says junior players only need 15 minutes. basically though at every level of hockey below junior, minor hockey kids get about 3-5 minutes between periods. I love hockey and love being at a rink, but can't stand going to NHL games because of the 40 minutes of dead time. I understand the recovery argument... but I really don't know how true that is... do you really get that revitalized? I mean if a sports scientist came out and said that it would then I guess... Intermissions used to be 15 minutes before TV.

That being said going down to 15 minutes only takes 10 minutes out of the game. Maybe if they did what soccer does and cut out commercials during the periods I wouldn't mind so much.
 

MattMang23

Adding Nothing to the Conversation
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
5,150
Reaction Score
14,742
I spend about 20 hours a week in a rink. *laugh*

Yup. I remember those days. Wouldn't have traded that time for anything. Of course I was the one playing and not standing in a cold building watching people play.

I understand the recovery argument... but I really don't know how true that is... do you really get that revitalized?

I always felt like I did. It takes probably a good ten minutes to get your body back to normal heart rate and feel ready to go back at it again. But I also stopped playing at 18. Not sure what the effect on the body is as an adult?

Cutting out the commericals would be ideal since there really are no assigned possession changes and the like and the puck rarely goes out of play. There really isn't a good time to take commerical breaks.

Hockey is just a bad TV product as it is. Greatest live game, worst TV game. I don't know that there is a real good fix for it.
 

ConnHuskBask

Shut Em Down!
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
8,962
Reaction Score
32,833
@HuskyHawk Definitely agree with your college hoops take. Two 20 minute halfs and almost always around 2 hours.

I'm a big baseball guy but unless it's Yankees playoffs, I usually have it on in the background and I'm doing something else until big spots or late innings.
 

Husky25

Dink & Dunk beat the Greatest Show on Turf.
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Messages
18,511
Reaction Score
19,487
Honestly, unless leagues institute Rugby 7s type amendments to their rules, I'm pretty much done watching games that don't include my favorite teams for about the next decade. Incidentally, Rugby 7s is terribly entertaining.

Football:
  • 7 on 7
  • 15 minute running halves
  • 15 second play clock
  • No huddles
  • Free substitution/no more Too many Men if the player is clearly not involved in the play.

Basketball
  • 3 on 3 (okay, 5 on 5 can stay)
  • 12 minute running halves.
  • Fouls are not called based on star power.
  • Traveling is called in the NBA
  • Constitutional Amendment stating that Zone is for sissies (exact wording) and outlawed on all levels.

Hockey
Honestly, hockey is quite entertaining as it is and games are still under 2 hours. I would still only watch the Bruins.

Baseball (This one is tough).
  • 15 second pitch clock.
  • Strike zone strictly enforced.
  • Batter is not allowed outside the batters box for any reason.
  • Only the catcher and first basemen are allowed to wear cups and only on defense (no cup, no junk pinching, less adjustments).
  • Catcher conferences count as mound visits.
  • Unless they are ejected or hurt, or they get the 3rd out of the inning, relief pitchers must face at least two full batters. If he gets those two out, he must pitch to a third. No more lefty specialists. You're a professional and making $5Mil/year for Pete's sake. Learn to throw down and in to a righty.
  • Two warm up tosses for relievers. You just got done throwing the ball for 10 minutes and spent the last 5 just standing there. You're warm. Two tosses to get used to the mound. Done.
International Soccer
  • Play to win. Retreating the ball all the way to your own keeper inside the box is an penalty kick from the dot.
  • Going down like you have a broken leg, and standing up 20 seconds later is a 5 minute power play for the other team.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
269
Reaction Score
628
Honestly, unless leagues institute Rugby 7s type amendments to their rules, I'm pretty much done watching games that don't include my favorite teams for about the next decade. Incidentally, Rugby 7s is terribly entertaining.

Football:
  • 7 on 7
  • 15 minute running halves
  • 15 second play clock
  • No huddles
  • Free substitution/no more Too many Men if the player is clearly not involved in the play.

Basketball
  • 3 on 3 (okay, 5 on 5 can stay)
  • 12 minute running halves.
  • Fouls are not called based on star power.
  • Traveling is called in the NBA
  • Constitutional Amendment stating that Zone is for sissies (exact wording) and outlawed on all levels.

Hockey
Honestly, hockey is quite entertaining as it is and games are still under 2 hours. I would still only watch the Bruins.

Baseball (This one is tough).
  • 15 second pitch clock.
  • Strike zone strictly enforced.
  • Batter is not allowed outside the batters box for any reason.
  • Only the catcher and first basemen are allowed to wear cups and only on defense (no cup, no junk pinching, less adjustments).
  • Catcher conferences count as mound visits.
  • Unless they are ejected or hurt, or they get the 3rd out of the inning, relief pitchers must face at least two full batters. If he gets those two out, he must pitch to a third. No more lefty specialists. You're a professional and making $5Mil/year for Pete's sake. Learn to throw down and in to a righty.
  • Two warm up tosses for relievers. You just got done throwing the ball for 10 minutes and spent the last 5 just standing there. You're warm. Two tosses to get used to the mound. Done.
International Soccer
  • Play to win. Retreating the ball all the way to your own keeper inside the box is an penalty kick from the dot.
  • Going down like you have a broken leg, and standing up 20 seconds later is a 5 minute power play for the other team.

My suggestions.

Football

1. Start the game clock 10 seconds after an incomplete pass or out of bounds, even under 2 minutes to go.
2. No two minute warning.
3. Must wait at least one minute of game time between time outs.
4. Broadcasting network must pay fine of $1 million each time camera is panned on Rex Ryan, Bill Belichek, Odell Beckham, Jr., among others.

Basketball

1. Must wait at least one minute of game time between time outs.
2. When there is less than two minutes left, the team that is fouled has the option of having ten seconds taken off the clock.
3. Fouls need to be called on merit, and not depend on star status.
4. Go back to calling the team from Ohio the "Cleveland Cavaliers," not "LeBron James and the Cleveland Cavaliers."

Hockey

Not too many complaints here. Yes, 20 minutes between periods can be a pain, but it seems that too many times, 20 minutes can go by between plays in baseball and football. Flopping/embellishment is an issue, of course, and will be addressed in soccer.

Baseball

1. No more than one pitching change in the middle of the inning.
2. No more than one conference between pitcher and catcher per inning.
3. If the catcher has to move his mitt to try to convince the umpire the pitch is a strike, it's an automatic ball.
4. Any team for any game has the option of having the DH.

Soccer

1. Significantly reduce the gross corruption and favortism in and around the game.
2. To reduce flopping, no foul should be called unless ref actually sees a foul.
3. If a player somehow gets hurt via incidental or no contact, player must submit to a protocol similar to concussions, which would have to include missing competitions for whatever appropriate time is needed to completely eliminate any strategic advantage of flopping. This rule can apply to all sports.
 

UCFBfan

Semi Kings of New England!
Joined
Jan 28, 2012
Messages
5,861
Reaction Score
11,701
I'm bouncing between the NFL game and the MLB game.

You want to make money streaming games? Play them in less than 4 hours.

Every play in the NFL game was under review and the game took forever. This is with both teams never taking a chance and kicking every field goal available.

Somehow even after a million penalties in the football game - the MLB game is still in the 7th inning.

If it ends in 9 innings the baseball game is still going to come in at over 4 hours.

The 7th inning of the baseball game took an hour and six minutes.

Other than people like me who is going to watch neverending slogs?
All the darn commercial breaks don't help either. I swear that CBS is the worst with this. It's just as bad when UConn plays on CBSSports Network. That game on Thursday had a sequence that went something like:

1. Team kicks field goal
2. Commercial
3. Team kicks off
4. Commercial
5. Team comes on field for one play. Injury happens
6. Commercial
7. Team runs one more play. Quarter ends
8. Commercial

It was insane. I mean seriously, you couldn't see that the clock was running down and after the injury just stay on the game for one more play? It was insane.

Thank god for RedZone and their no commercials policy. It makes watching football more tolerable, especially since I only care about the majority of those games for fantasy purposes.
 

Online statistics

Members online
175
Guests online
2,768
Total visitors
2,943

Forum statistics

Threads
156,894
Messages
4,069,669
Members
9,951
Latest member
Woody69


Top Bottom