Our victory ... every year UConn (2003-2009) was predicted #75-105 in preseason annuals. Most every year, HCRE (in my view) broke the top 50 in teams in the country; and maybe we were top 30 at one moment. I think HCRE can get there again. However, make no mistake, while our Fanbase and National view sees the Big East as NAME BRAND opposition in that time frame, this AAC is actually a better consistent quality team week in week out. (excepting my view of WVU)
Your memory is a little hazy. Uconn started exceeding preseason predictions in 2007. I have the links to conference consensus finish by year and the actual years below but here are the results:
2003 - NAP (not in the Big East)
2004 - Preseason 5; actual 5
2005 - Preseason 6 actual 6
2006 - Preseason 6 actual 7
2007 - Preseason 7 actual tied for 1st (AP rank of 16 at one point; unranked end of season)
2008 - Preseason 6 actual 5 (AP had Uconn ranked 24 at one point that year)
2009 - Preseason 6 actual 4
2004-2006, Uconn was not one of the top 50 teams in the country. They had their share of upsets and highly competitive games during those years and you could see the progress but 2007 was just one of those years where all the pieces fit and all the breaks Uconn needed for the tie breaker went their way including the head to head win over UWV.
2007 Big East Conference Year Summary | College Football at Sports-Reference.com
2003 Preseason Consensus