Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="eebmg, post: 2269183, member: 7548"] While I did not mention their draft positions in my first post, it was part of my thinking in being somewhat critical of McBride's play. Nothing wrong in refining an argument. I think it is quite reasonable to assess player performance by their potential. If a top 5 player is not playing like a top 5 player, that is a problem. I would put Plum in that mix except she is a rookie. Regarding consistency, I was not looking at numbers directly but through my own observations of all the SA games. (Never miss a MoJeff game) Imho, she is a volume shooter who once in a while gets red hot but other times is ice cold. That is the definition of inconsistency in my book. Maybe saying Isabelle "becoming a star" is too strong for some but when I see a very young player make such a sharp improvement, I am generally optimistic that it is not a fluke and she will continue to develop further. [/QUOTE]