And the only reason Cal doesn't have 3 from the last 4 years is because of UConn. Does that make him a good coach?
Yeah. Whether we like it or not, Cal is a pretty good coach....He's
1) a game coach,
2) a solid-to-good developer (look at his UMass and Memphis teams...he hasn't kept a lot of UK players, and those he has haven't developed as well as others in the past), and
3) perhaps the best recruiter ever. That makes him a good coach.
Compare that with Rick Barnes, who's a terrible game coach, a poor developer, and a good recruiter.
The results: Calipari has 1 title, 5 Final Fours; Barnes has 1 Final Four.
We can criticize him for weak game coaching, but in college basketball that's only about a third of job, and he's pretty darn good at the others.