Harper vs Edgecombe.

[UconnU]

Friends and I had a heated debate tonight, so I thought it would be a good topic. Who makes the better pro?

 

[caw]

Oddly think they’d fit better on opposite teams. Harper on 6ers. Edgecombe on Spurs. Bc they overlap with players already on their current teams.

I say Edgecombe starts off better but Harper ends up with a better career.

 

[Huskyforlife]

Oddly think they’d fit better on opposite teams. Harper on 6ers. Edgecombe on Spurs. Bc they overlap with players already on their current teams.

I say Edgecombe starts off better but Harper ends up with a better career.

Harper overlaps more with Maxey and McCain though.

 

[Mr. French]

I think they're both going to be good - as is Tre Johnson. I think VJ could be like an Ant, and Harper is going to be like a Cade. Not necessarily AS good, but that would be the high-end projections.

I feel like Fears, Bailey and Maluach will be less "good" than they are projected, whatever that means.

 

[navery12]

I think they'll both be very good, but Harper will be the better player. He has the PG skills that I think Edgecombe lacks, so I don't see that experiment going well for him. Neither one has a particularly easy path to playing PG like they want though, so that'll be interesting

 

[Mr. French]

I think they'll both be very good, but Harper will be the better player. He has the PG skills that I think Edgecombe lacks, so I don't see that experiment going well for him. Neither one has a particularly easy path to playing PG like they want though, so that'll be interesting

I hadn't seen the buzz about Edgecombe trying to play PG, is that what HE wants? He seems like the perfect 2G, I am kind of flummoxed by that.

Harper seems like he's always been that big lead guard type, in mentality. Ironically, similar to Castle but with different styles.

 

[caw]

Harper overlaps more with Maxey and McCain though.

I personally think Harper fits well with McCain and while Maxey is a great player and pretty ball dominant, he's not really a true PG.

 

[controlfade]

personally, Bailey was prolly the best fit for the Sixers with their current roster

 

[navery12]

I hadn't seen the buzz about Edgecombe trying to play PG, is that what HE wants? He seems like the perfect 2G, I am kind of flummoxed by that.

Harper seems like he's always been that big lead guard type, in mentality. Ironically, similar to Castle but with different styles.

Guess it could be a 76ers thing but this was what I saw. I thought I saw another quote that was more explicit but can't find it now

 

[Lafayette]

Guess it could be a 76ers thing but this was what I saw. I thought I saw another quote that was more explicit but can't find it now

McCain - Shooting Guard
Maxey - Point Guard
VG - Combo Guard

Sixer can get by with Maxey and VJ and push McCain down to bench guard. All depends if they want 3 bigs (Embiid, George, Oubre) or 3 guards.

Let's see how VG plays out in the Summer League as there is no way Maxey is pushed to the bench but McCain could be.