A few years ago, we used Phoenix Travel of Fairfield owned by Arianna and it worked out well. 475-225-1553, I believe. We are in New Haven county so we now use someone, more local.
Surprisingly recently, when our ride (not Phoenix) got stuck in NY traffic on out last JFK trip in May and a little panic set in, we called Uber and it was $156 vs $200 for original ride. We were lucky the NY Uber driver had just dropped someone off locally and got there in 10 minutes. Our original driver picked us up on the return trip and offered to waive his fee. We paid him the Uber price.
As a general comment, if you ever use a local Uber driver, they'll offer their direct non-Uber phone number, which usually cheaper than Uber.
En joy your journey