Big East Preseason Awards & Coaches' Poll

[rjp172]

We've seen it in national polls and I think coaches sometimes keep the mentality of "its theirs until someone takes it away". Didn't UConn get some 1st place preseason votes in the national poll last year and that was the reason given? Of course UConn should win going away this year, but strange things happen in these polls. I was surprised last year when it was a 7-6 split (i think, if not close) between ND and UConn. I thought what UConn loss far outweighed what ND loss.

Faris was a victim of UConn's success. With 3 players on the 1st team and PFOY there aren't a lot of coaches likely to put a 5th name on a ballot. Mallory had nearly the same success with guarding the other teams best players and she never got so much as a sniff or even a veiled mention of possibly being worthy of any All BE spot not alone 1st team. Defense is appreciated but stats are awarded. Rodgers is a good case in point. She won FOY because of her scoring line on a team that she was a volume shooter. Not sure there is a player that's a "glaring" omission, but there are some players that are going to put up some great stat lines and may not make the teams because of the need to spread it around. DePaul's Harry and Penny will put up some good scoring and rebounding numbers this season. McBride is likely to lead ND in scoring. She might be the least heralded player in the BE.

 

[MilfordHusky]

Shoni Schimmel is unanimous 1st team, but Kaleena Mosqueda-Lewis is not.

www.YouTube.com/Watch?v=zANvYB93u2g

 

[HuskyFan1125]

I understand why Diggins is picked preseason, but not confident she will be the award winner by season end!! I think her role will drastically change this year as she will likely be the primary scoring option. Just a guess!

Let the season begin!

 

[VAUConnFan]

Leading in steals does not make the best defender, think Angel McCoughtry. I thought Mallory was ND's best defender but Peters won because she blocked a lot of shots. Coaches naturally look for a stat to justify a pick because it's easy.

Ms McCoughtry was, in fact, the 2009 Big East Defensive Player of the Year. She led the Big East in scoring, rebounds, and steals three consecutive seasons.

While I agree that being a steals leader or a leading shot blocker does not make one the best defender, having the stats is what gets the votes for the awards; Especially when the voters do not see the players night in and night out.

Last year, in addition to blocking a lot of shots, Devereaux Peters was the league's second leading rebounder on a team that finished atop the standings.

 

[Kevin G]

Wow, Skylar was NOT a unanimous selection for player of the year, interesting.

I guess someone took in the consideration of her "classy" attitude

 

[Kevin G]

Shoni Schimmel is unanimous 1st team, but Kaleena Mosqueda-Lewis is not.

www.YouTube.com/Watch?v=zANvYB93u2g[/quote]



I'm guessing those voters only looked at statistics. Sure Schimmel averages 14pts/game but she takes 30-35 shots a game. If KML did that she would be averaging 30+/game

 

[baggerbob]

No one from Notre Dame is having a career day against Uconn this year. Breanna isn't to bad at help defense and with Geno teaching will only get better. Skylar might find a lot of shots from all places on the floor coming back at her.

 

[PacoSwede]

I think it's a pretty good bet that Kelly Faris is going to be playing basketball at the highest level a lot longer than most of the people on that honors list. But, it's not surprising she wasn't mentioned at the BE show. Hell, she doesn't even get the recognition she deserves HERE in the BY, though this thread does show many do appreciate her value.
Defensive POY? Nice thought, but let's not pigeonhole her as a defensive player. She a great rebounder and is a superb assist person, really valuable with the offensive flow. Then of course, there's the hustle factor ... continuing the UConn legacy of finding such players.

 

[baggerbob]

No one else in the country will be bringing off the bench a player, who in 4 yrs might be one of the 5 best to ever play the game. Breanna never started for the USA teams until the knockout rounds, and could care less as long as they win. She knew when she chose Uconn she wouldn't start as a freshman, the reason she stated at the time, was she wanted to become the best player she could be, and Geno and Uconn were where that will happen.

 

[doggydaddy]

McBride is likely to lead ND in scoring. She might be the least heralded player in the BE.

I'm not buying it. McBride is a terrific player and I don't know anyone that doesn't know that.

Just because she didn't make a BE pre-season team doesn't mean she is not heralded.