Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="auror, post: 4184084, member: 1329"] My preference is for total defensive value and I'm noting that the positions do not provide this value equally on defense, and so from his position he has to do certain things to really make a difference, and he only does 1 of the options at a high level (1v1 individual defense, not disrupting offense or protecting the rim). If you want to say he's one of the 3 best individual 1v1 wing defenders in the league, sure I agree he's up there. Should a wing defender who doesn't cause steals and is not an elite rim protector be the DPOY in the conference? From my perspective, that type of player does not add enough total defensive value in most cases. [/QUOTE]