Are Wooden, K or Calhoun...... | The Boneyard

Are Wooden, K or Calhoun......

Chin Diesel

Power of Love
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
33,438
Reaction Score
104,729
Or Knight, John Thompson or Izzo considered "lesser" coaches by peers, media or fans because they stayed on college rather than testing the pros?

Do people think they are lesser coaches than Riley, Pop, Jackson, etc?

Would love to see Hurley stay in NCAA and do the K thing of positioning himself for national team coaching and winning Olympic gold.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
5,339
Reaction Score
23,690
Or Knight, John Thompson or Izzo considered "lesser" coaches by peers, media or fans because they stayed on college rather than testing the pros?

Do people think they are lesser coaches than Riley, Pop, Jackson, etc?

Would love to see Hurley stay in NCAA and do the K thing of positioning himself for national team coaching and winning Olympic gold.
I'm laughing at the thought of Danny trying to coach a team of all star prima donnas.
 
Joined
Nov 11, 2018
Messages
2,092
Reaction Score
9,486
I think social media and the internet changes everything. People barely remember coach k, or izzo being courted by the NBA.
This one was elevated!
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
9,380
Reaction Score
34,286
No, nobody cares if you prove yourself in the NBA. I'd argue that only Pop and Phil Jackson really even have a lot of clout among NBA coaches in terms of being legendary. The college game is much more about the coaches than the NBA is. The NBA is a player's league.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
3,747
Reaction Score
12,077
I think there are far more legendary college coaches that NBA. Obviously, college guys get a bit more longevity. But I was always questioning the notion that Hurley going the NBA would finalize his legend.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
2,304
Reaction Score
4,010
Or Knight, John Thompson or Izzo considered "lesser" coaches by peers, media or fans because they stayed on college rather than testing the pros?

Do people think they are lesser coaches than Riley, Pop, Jackson, etc?

Would love to see Hurley stay in NCAA and do the K thing of positioning himself for national team coaching and winning Olympic gold.
I would also like Danny Hurley to do the thing that aligns 100% with my own personal preferences as well
 
Joined
Mar 29, 2022
Messages
192
Reaction Score
1,543
The college game has always been framed around the coaches because the players have much shorter playing careers there.

I don't think anyone would try to convince you Coach K was a better coach than Phil Jackson. But I think anyone would realize they each probably couldn't have done what the other did. Just very different coaches and styles for a different level of the game.

The new NBA has devolved into coaches being yes men. Coaches don't have the say and power they did 20 years ago in the NBA. The best jobs in the NBA are now what Riley and Steven's do. It's a totally different dynamic.

Hurley has come along at the perfect time for college basketball. He hails from a basketball royalty family but a family that had to earn everything and did it while being devoutly loyal and stubborn to anyone around them. He's interesting, he's extremely popular among his players while also being hated by opponents and their fan bases and he wins. He's the perfect mixture of what makes a great college coach at a time when a lot of those personalities are gone or are dwindling.

Hurley may go to the NBA someday and he may end up being a good coach there but I think the biggest part of his legacy will always be what he's done and is doing in college at Uconn. It'll be hard to ever eclipse that in the pros.
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
12,874
Reaction Score
21,486
Or Knight, John Thompson or Izzo considered "lesser" coaches by peers, media or fans because they stayed on college rather than testing the pros?

Do people think they are lesser coaches than Riley, Pop, Jackson, etc?

Would love to see Hurley stay in NCAA and do the K thing of positioning himself for national team coaching and winning Olympic gold.
I don’t think those are comparable jobs honestly.
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
12,874
Reaction Score
21,486
No, nobody cares if you prove yourself in the NBA. I'd argue that only Pop and Phil Jackson really even have a lot of clout among NBA coaches in terms of being legendary. The college game is much more about the coaches than the NBA is. The NBA is a player's league.
I agree with this. There was a time when NBA coaches were legendary. But that was long ago. Jackson was really the last of them. But back in the day you had Auerbach, Red Hotlzman of the Knicks, Heinson, Pat Riley. They were part of the fabric of their teams. Now it is some guy named Moe. Heck the head coach of the Boston Celtics, another legendary team, was coaching D2 Fairmont State in 2019. Which btw is his only head coaching experience. And he is just as likely to be out on his butt if the team doesn’t win it all this year as he is to be back. If that happens, he’ll end up in Brooklyn or Detroit or wherever there is an opening next year. Or look at Thibidau with the Knicks, Timberwolves, Bulls after 20 years as an assistant in various places. He is the prototypical NBA head coach. Start as an Assistant, then move up. Wear out your welcome in one town and move on to the next.
 
Joined
Aug 12, 2023
Messages
17
Reaction Score
72
Or Knight, John Thompson or Izzo considered "lesser" coaches by peers, media or fans because they stayed on college rather than testing the pros?

Do people think they are lesser coaches than Riley, Pop, Jackson, etc?

Would love to see Hurley stay in NCAA and do the K thing of positioning himself for national team coaching and winning Olympic gold.
Name the top five NBA coaches.
Then name the top 5 college coaches.
Tell me who has the higher "mindshare".
College coaches are far more respected than NBA coaches IMO.
 

McLovin

Gangstas, what's up?
Joined
Dec 3, 2018
Messages
2,965
Reaction Score
18,878
How do you even begin to define greater or lesser? There really isn't any way to do an apples to apples comparison of career accomplishments or even X & O skills.

I am probably biased because I'm a college hoops junkie, but my opinion is that the top college coaches of the last quarter century would have just as much name recognition to the average sports fan as the top NBA coaches. And I bet the average sports fan could name more current college coaches than current NBA coaches.
 

McLovin

Gangstas, what's up?
Joined
Dec 3, 2018
Messages
2,965
Reaction Score
18,878
I think there has only been 1 guy to ever win a title in both college and the NBA and that's Larry Brown. When I think of what makes the NBA appealing to Hurley, it isn't the prestige of being looked at as a top coach / basketball mind - most of his colleagues and the general public would agree he is already - it's the chance to do something only 1 other person has ever done before.

He is a guy who always wants to push the envelope, and if he ever does go for the NBA I think THAT will be the legacy he will be shooting for (not just being looked at as better or whatever).
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
7,514
Reaction Score
25,092
There is only one solid reason IMO to go to the NBA and that is more money. All of the other reasons are highly subjective.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
2,017
Reaction Score
7,541
I find it tough to understand why Hurley would want to coach an NBA team. But if that's his dream, then I hope he gets to pursue it someday. However, he'll be giving up what is currently the best job in college basketball, and he'll be taking a risk in terms of personal happiness. He'll also be closing out his legacy as it relates to UConn. At some point maybe he'll change his mind about coaching anywhere but here. I sure hope so.
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2023
Messages
138
Reaction Score
1,046
There is only one solid reason IMO to go to the NBA and that is more money. All of the other reasons are highly subjective.
There’s more money but also less work. It’s a much longer season but you don’t have to do recruiting or portal or NIL stuff. Scouting is way easier. There’s a lot more time off.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
7,514
Reaction Score
25,092
There’s more money but also less work. It’s a much longer season but you don’t have to do recruiting or portal or NIL stuff. Scouting is way easier. There’s a lot more time off.

That is highly subjective.

BTW recruiting has always been difficult in college, I don't really buy the idea that it is tougher now, and least it is no longer dirty and the coaches no longer have to worry about an NCAA investigation. Kelvin Samson once lost his job over phone calls and texts. We all saw the scrutiny Calhoun had to endure. UConn is at the top of the recruiting food chain right now. Karaban is in the NBA if not for NIL.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 16, 2015
Messages
3,554
Reaction Score
10,222
I don't think of them as lesser coaches... but I do think of them as control freaks that would struggle dealing with adult men who have more organization pull than the coach. I always think of PJ's transition to the pros and wonder if JC would of had similar issues.
 
Joined
Nov 1, 2014
Messages
77
Reaction Score
440
Yea I think Wooden is every bit as legendary as Auerbach, probably more. K, Jimmy, Izzo etc were more revered than all the coaches in their prime era except maybe Pop and Phil. And now, Spo is probably the best coach and he's not even discussed much generally.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
3,747
Reaction Score
12,077
Yea I think Wooden is every bit as legendary as Auerbach, probably more. K, Jimmy, Izzo etc were more revered than all the coaches in their prime era except maybe Pop and Phil. And now, Spo is probably the best coach and he's not even discussed much generally.

I mean in my lifetime (I'm 44), the "legendary" NBA coaches are probably Phil, Pop, Riley, Chuck Daly, Spoelstra, Kerr, and maybe KC Jones? Lenny Wilkens? And even that list, I think, has distinct "tiers" within it. But that's 8 guys in 44 years. There's easily 5-6 times the amount of college coaches who fit into the "legend" category.
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2023
Messages
361
Reaction Score
1,628
Or Knight, John Thompson or Izzo considered "lesser" coaches by peers, media or fans because they stayed on college rather than testing the pros?

Do people think they are lesser coaches than Riley, Pop, Jackson, etc?

Would love to see Hurley stay in NCAA and do the K thing of positioning himself for national team coaching and winning Olympic gold.
Ask the followup question to get the answer - who is a great college coach that went on to also be a great NBA coach. I mean, there might be one, but I'm not aware of it, frankly.
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2023
Messages
361
Reaction Score
1,628
I find it tough to understand why Hurley would want to coach an NBA team. But if that's his dream, then I hope he gets to pursue it someday. However, he'll be giving up what is currently the best job in college basketball, and he'll be taking a risk in terms of personal happiness. He'll also be closing out his legacy as it relates to UConn. At some point maybe he'll change his mind about coaching anywhere but here. I sure hope so.
I would tend to agree with you if it were just going to coach just any NBA team. Before last year, that may have been a distant dream of Hurley's - to coach in the NBA. But now ? He just turned down the Lakers. He should be able to pick the job he wants, within reason, assuming nothing crazy happens. As a NJ guy, maybe getting to be the Knicks head coach is a dream job, regardless of the difficulties of coaching in the NBA. I get that.
 
Joined
Aug 25, 2011
Messages
16,683
Reaction Score
33,025
How many jobs do you know of where the employee makes more than the boss?

Many NBA coaches its a money grab (and rightfully so), switching from team to team (e.g. Rivers, Williams) because teams are in a win now scenario. No time to build, empty seats means empty revenue.

Just saying how the hell do you get someone who makes more than you to work harder (i.e. practice) at 100%? Yelling just going to piss them off. And Dan is about culture change.

Imagine Danny coaching Draymond Green.
 
Last edited:

FfldCntyFan

Texas: Property of UConn Men's Basketball program
Joined
Aug 25, 2011
Messages
13,236
Reaction Score
47,546
What the general public thinks may not really matter as in most cases it would come down to personal preference. Some of these coaches may truly believe that they need to accomplish something at the highest professional level while others are content with something other than that.

Tell me, do you think Bob Hurley Sr. views himself as a less accomplished coach because he never coached beyond high school?

At the moment Danny sees the NBA as a challenge that at some point he would like to attempt. His thought process may change as he continues here but it also may become more important to him to give it a shot.

The one thing that I am fully confident in is that while he is here he will continue to be what he currently is, a relentless worker who won't ever rest on his prior accomplishments.
 

Online statistics

Members online
301
Guests online
1,906
Total visitors
2,207

Forum statistics

Threads
159,739
Messages
4,202,503
Members
10,073
Latest member
CTEspn


.
Top Bottom