Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Oldbones, post: 3033137, member: 5753"] [QUOTE=" In my younger days, the "who's best" controversy was between Willie Mays and Mickey Mantle. QUOTE] [B]In my younger days, it was a three horse race. They starred for three different teams, all world series winner right on top of each other, all same city. [/B] [B]We BYers are blessed to have both Pheesa and Lou, same team, same time. I suspect the only controversy here is generated by us.[/B] [B]Just like the constant 3-23-30 who is best argument by us BHYers, We who grew up in the early fifties had the 4-7-24 discussion. I prefer comparing players of different teams (4-7-24) or different time periods (3-23-30) Same-team comparisons can be divisive.[/B] [ATTACH=full]39439[/ATTACH] [B]By the way, who was the best?[/B] [/QUOTE]