Don't we need to see if Gaffney is ready before reaching a conclusion like that. I'm not going to say he isn't but for the injury, but until we see more than we've seen that seems premature.
No. The other 50% of this consideration is limiting Gilbert's minutes.
Remember as kid, your mother telling you to tell your brother (Sister, Dad, whathaveyou) that dinner is ready, and you scream at the top of your lungs in their general direction that dinner was ready? What was Mom's inevitable retort? Always, "Well, I could have done that."
That's how I feel about Gilbert at this point. I empathize with his injury history, but anyone can run directly into The Trees and throw up an airball lay up.
Gaffney's unknown floor is worth more to me than Gilbert's known ceiling.